
Nuclear Notes is produced by the Breakthrough Institute, and covers the policy, regulation, technology, and business of advanced nuclear energy in the United States and beyond.
Every Thursday, we track what’s really going on in the field: the new rules moving through the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the advanced reactors moving from design to deployment, the companies going public and the utilities merging, and the executive orders and acts of Congress reshaping how the country builds. We explain not just what happened, but why it matters and how the pieces fit together.
The New York Power Authority Takes Another Step Towards Building
The New York Power Authority, ordered by Governor Kathy Hochul to develop one gigawatt of new nuclear capacity, has concluded a round in its multi-stage process to determine the who, what, and where of building. It has qualified ten companies with a variety of technologies and track records.
The Power Authority issued a “Request for Qualifications” in June, and 23 developers and potential partners responded. The request said the authority wanted a large reactor “such as the AP1000” or a small modular reactor “such as the BWRX-300,” but the state still has not said what it will actually build. It has said that it wants a proven technology, which would seem to rule out everything but light-water reactors, but its list includes one company with a gas-cooled graphite-moderated design and another that is building a sodium-cooled fast reactor.
Entities that want to build new reactors may be holding off until decisions are made by the Energy Department, which has proposed $17.5 billion in loan guarantees for the long-lead-time items for ten AP1000 models, but has not said who will get the loan help.
The ten companies that have now been qualified will be eligible to participate when the Power Authority issues a Request for Proposals:
Avangrid, which is the parent company of two utilities in the state, New York State Electric & Gas, and Rochester Gas & Electric. The company also owns utilities in New England, and operates in 25 states.
Elementl Power, a four-year-old company based in Washington, D.C., that says it has 1.5 gigawatts of nuclear energy “in development” and has expertise in “capital formation, project execution, regulatory strategy, and nuclear energy with a technology-agnostic, capital-efficient approach.”
NextEra Energy, the parent company of Florida Power & Light (FPL) and NextEra Energy Resources. FPL operates Turkey Point and St. Lucie in Florida and NextEra Energy Resources operates Point Beach in Wisconsin and Seabrook in New Hampshire, and holds a majority interest in the Duane Arnold Energy Center in Iowa, which shut down in 2020 and is targeted for restart by 2029.
Oppenheimer Energy, founded two years ago by Charles Oppenheimer, grandson of J. Robert Oppenheimer, the Manhattan Project guru, bills itself as a developer that can handle licensing, design, procurement, and even offtake agreements.
The Nuclear Company, a start-up that wants to build a series of Westinghouse AP1000 reactors, using “one operating model, one data backbone, and one institutional memory.” It has a plan for up to six reactors on the Ohio River in Kentucky, although at the moment this is little more than a potential site and a proposal.
Turquoise Power, a start-up that wants to build SMRs that will provide both electricity and heat.
Blue Energy says it can cut the time to completion to three years by prefabricating small modular reactors at non-nuclear commercial shipyards and industrial fabrication yards, and cut the cost to $5,000 per kilowatt with successive projects. The NRC recently accepted for review the company’s application for a construction permit for a GE Vernova Hitachi BWRX-300 small modular reactor that it wants to build in Victoria County, Texas.
Holtec International is a well-established nuclear company that builds heat exchangers and dry casks for used fuel storage, but wants to branch out into building a 300-megawatt SMR. It has proposed two of those on the site of the Palisades reactor, which it purchased to decommission but is now preparing to restart.
TerraPower, a company backed by Bill Gates and other tech investors, is building a fast reactor coupled with a heat storage system, so it can change its output in reaction to grid needs and wholesale prices. The lead plant is in Kemmerer, Wyoming. It is one of two on the list that is not a light-water reactor.
X-energy is the other non-light-water reactor. Its design uses TRISO fuel and a helium coolant. It recently received a construction permit for a lead plant at a Dow chemical plant in Texas.
Companies had to “demonstrate a credible path to both produce 1+ GW of energy and start construction before 2033.” That year is the deadline for investment tax credits under the Inflation Reduction Act. The Power Authority said that each of the ten had “demonstrated the technical expertise or project-delivery experience required to support an advanced nuclear energy generation project, and provided NYPA with information on applicable nuclear technologies.”
This list of developers is relevant beyond the NY project. The list of ten is a who’s who of potential builders around the United States. But these ten do not necessarily reflect the top 10 developers who are closest to commercialization.
The Power Authority did not say whom it had excluded. But the list has several obvious omissions. Westinghouse, the original contractor for Vogtle Units 3 and 4, was not listed. Its AP1000 technology is also central to plans to complete the two unfinished reactors at V.C. Summer, where a joint venture between Brookfield and The Nuclear Company has been selected as the prospective project manager. Nor was Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power, which built the four-unit Barakah complex in the United Arab Emirates and is eager to use its expertise on another project. And NuScale Power, which has an NRC-approved design for a nuclear plant that could comprise a dozen small reactor modules, was also not mentioned.
What Will Make Nuclear’s Resurgence Durable?
The momentum behind nuclear energy is undeniable. At this week’s American Nuclear Society Winter Conference in Phoenix, Arizona, which was attended by roughly 1,500 professionals, from students to government officials and industry leaders, the excitement was palpable, and for good reason. After a year of major regulatory reforms, policy changes, and technical milestones, the industry has plenty to celebrate. But given this year’s conference theme, “Creating a Durable Nuclear Resurgence,” the Breakthrough Nuclear Team, which was in attendance, was struck by how little discussion actually focused on what will make the momentum last.
One message came through clearly: developers have to deliver. The federal government has undertaken sweeping regulatory reforms, provided substantial incentives, and demonstrated its willingness to support nuclear development. There is certainly more work to be done on the policy and regulatory front, at both the federal and state level, but these efforts ultimately need to translate into reactors being built and operated.
During a panel featuring the CEOs from the four developers that achieved criticality through DOE’s Reactor Pilot Program by July 4th this year, their determination was evident. Despite the challenges and setbacks they encountered, the developers spoke enthusiastically about what they had learned and what comes next.
However, the Breakthrough team heard fewer concrete ideas for addressing the challenges that could threaten the durability of this resurgence. Fuel supply, workforce development, financing, and manufacturing capacity are hardly new concerns; they are well understood across the industry and acknowledging them is important. But identifying barriers is not the same as developing credible plans to overcome them.
Telling Congress to Fix the Rules on Spent Nuclear Fuel
Ten leading nuclear advocacy groups, including the Breakthrough Institute, have sent a letter to the leaders of the appropriations and energy committees of both chambers of Congress advocating to give the Energy Department the authority to engage with states that volunteer to reprocess spent nuclear fuel, and potentially store the waste.
The letter says, “After years of gridlock, we are in an unprecedented moment in which states are interested in working with DOE to explore the full nuclear fuel cycle. To maintain that interest, DOE needs sufficient authority, accountability, and transparency to advance those conversations.”
The groups would like Congress to act during the lame duck session, giving the department funding to begin preliminary site evaluation and engagement. But the Nuclear Waste Fund would be preserved for use in building a repository.
Signatories include the Nuclear Energy Institute, which represents the nuclear industry; the U.S. Nuclear Industry Council, whose members include advanced reactor developers and vendors; and the Nuclear Waste Strategy Coalition, which is comprised of state and local governments and other stakeholders concerned with the management and disposal of spent nuclear fuel, including states and communities that no longer have reactors but still have dry cask storage installations.
NRC Prepares for Mass Reactor Deployment
The Atomic Energy Act requires the NRC’s Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards (ACRS), an independent committee of technical experts, to review certain reactor license applications and advise the Commission on safety matters. But that requirement does not mean every application needs the same level of scrutiny, particularly when safety issues have been resolved in earlier reviews.
The NRC has now issued a rule in this direction to focus the committee’s work on “first-of-a-kind designs, emerging safety issues and other matters where the Committee’s independent technical expertise can provide the greatest value.” The idea is to steer the committee to “novel and safety-significant issues.”
The rule takes effect in late January unless the agency receives “significant adverse comments.”
Sixteen Billion Miles on Nuclear Energy
Voyager 2, the man-made object furthest from the Earth, reached a distance of one light-day yesterday, November 18. Voyager 1 is nearly as far away. The Voyager spaceships’ instruments run on heat made by the radioactive decay of 13.5 kilograms of plutonium-238, which has a half-life of 87.7 years. At launch, each of Voyager’s three radio-isotope thermoelectric generators put out a combined 470 watts of electrical power, but the spacecraft loses about four watts a year.
That number is becoming more significant because both Voyagers are now more than 49 years old, which may be longer than some of its designers expected them to operate. As its energy supply dwindles, some instruments have been shut down, but both Voyagers still communicate with Earth. The radio signals take 24 hours in each direction.
The Voyagers may run into the 2030s.
Thanks for reading!




Jean, an interesting feature of the new designs is that they are "walk-away safe," meaning that no operator action is needed to prevent core damage. They employ passive safety features like gravity and natural heat circulation. But I think that the last 50 years have shown that even current designs are safe, compared to other energy options.
I am all for modern, safe, nuclear energy. At least as a segway to all clean energy in the future. The danger/limitations have always been human competence. Perhaps AI will fix this, but then who minds the minders?